Our most popular recipe every Thanksgiving is this one. For good reason too! One of the most popular sides from Boston Market is waiting to be served on your table. Our newest copycat recipe, Sweet Potato Casserole, is one for your recipe book! Rich sweet potatoes covered in marshmallow and brown sugar streusel topping is a side dish to remember.
When Chad and I were first dating, most weekends, we would pick up a movie and head to Boston Market.
We would order our favorite meatloaf and sides for dinner and take it to go. There is nothing quite like Boston Market meatloaf and sweet potato casserole, well except their corn bread.
That is pretty fabulous too.
On our way back to Chad's apartment we would stop and pick up a pint of ice cream. Then we would sit down and enjoy our dinner while we watched The X-Files.
Do you remember that show? Oh we watched it every week. That was a great sci-fi series!
These days it's more like Walking Dead. That is our favorite horror series now. But, in true form we sit down every week and enjoy that show.
Is it just me or do you enjoy staying at home? We like going out every now and then but truth be told we are homebodies.
Being at home just fits. Whether we are having game night, throwing parties or just cuddling up to a great movie, being at home is a good fit.
Growing up my parents never went out without us. I could probably count on one hand the number of times we had a babysitter.
Perhaps watching my parents for the 42 years they were married, a few things rubbed off on me.
Whether its for Thanksgiving or a movie night this copycat Boston Market Sweet Potato Casserole is going to blow your mind.
Rich mashed sweet potatoes with butter, cream, brown sugar and spices are topped with marshmallow and a scrumptious crisp brown sugar streusel. The ultimate side for any meal.
Speaking of simple recipes, of course our new cookbook {The Simple Kitchen - available to order now}is packed with delicious, easy recipes.
The Simple Kitchen is loaded with more than 75 BRAND NEW recipes and a hand full of family favorites too.
8 chapters with a total of 82 quick and easy recipes that are bursting with flavor!!!
Every recipe has a photo that will make your mouth water. It has slow cooker meals, one-pot recipes, quick dinners, simple appetizers, desserts and more!!!
And we have included kitchen tips to make dinnertime less stressful.
We are so excited to share our recipes with you!!! So, don't wait. Go and grab yours today! The Simple Kitchen <-- click here to order.
Helpful Tips to make Boston Market Copycat Sweet Potato Casserole:
- Make sure you cook the potatoes until fork tender. I know everyone is in a hurry but you can't recover from undercooked sweet potatoes and no one wants crunchy sweet potato casserole.
What you will need to make Boston Market Copycat Sweet Potato Casserole:
- Electric Hand Mixer - I have had this one in my kitchen forever (it seems like) at least 8 years.
Enjoy!
With love from our simple kitchen to yours.
Do you ❤ love ❤ TSRI? Don't miss another recipe. Click here to Subscribe to The Slow Roasted Italian by Email and receive new recipes in your inbox every day!
Check out more of our favorite Thanksgiving recipes:
Best Ever Slow Cooker Creamed Corn5 Star Brown Gravy
The Best Stuffing Recipe Ever
See how easy this Boston Market Copycat Sweet Potato Casserole is to make. Watch the video!!!
Yield: 12
Boston Market Copycat Sweet Potato Casserole
One of the most popular sides from Boston Market is waiting to be served on your table. Our newest copycat recipe, Sweet Potato Casserole, is one for your recipe book! Rich sweet potatoes covered in marshmallow and brown sugar streusel topping is a side dish to remember.
Ingredients
Sweet Potatoes
- 3 1/2 - 4 pounds sweet potatoes, peeled and cut into 1” pieces
- 4 tablespoons (1/2 stick) unsalted butter
- 3/4 cup packed light brown sugar
- 1/2 cup heavy cream
- 1 teaspoon kosher salt
- 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract
- 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
Topping
- 2 cups mini marshmallows
- 1/2 cup all-purpose flour
- 4 tablespoons butter unsalted butter
- 6 tablespoons packed light brown sugar
- 1/4 cup old fashioned rolled oats
- 1/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon
Instructions
- Fill a large pot with sweet potato pieces and water. Bring to a boil over high heat. Cook until fork tender. Drain potatoes and place back into pot. Mash potatoes with a potato masher or blend with an electric mixer, until mostly smooth. Add remaining ingredients (except topping ingredients). Mix until combined.
- Preheat oven to 350°F. Grease an 8”x10” casserole dish (8x8 or 9x9 works too).
- Spoon sweet potatoes into casserole dish and smooth out. Sprinkle top of sweet potatoes with marshmallows.
- Melt butter in a medium microwave safe bowl. Add remaining ingredients. Mix with a fork. Sprinkle over top of casserole.
- Bake for 20-25 minutes until streusel is crisp and marshmallows are golden brown.
- Serve and enjoy!
Recipe developed by Donna Elick The Slow Roasted Italian
Copyright ©2013 The Slow Roasted Italian – All rights reserved.
Copyright ©2013 The Slow Roasted Italian – All rights reserved.
Disclosure: Posts may contain affiliate links. If you purchase a product through an affiliate link your price will remain the same and The Slow Roasted Italian will automatically receive a small commission. Thank you for supporting us, it helps us keep creating new recipes.
Can I use anything besides heavy cream in the sweet potato casseroles?
ReplyDeleteYou can substitute with half and half, milk, almond milk, soy milk... The flavor of each will change the casserole, but it will still be fabulous!
DeleteDonna, this brings back memories of my childhood! This is just like the old fashioned sweet potato casserole my mom made for Thanksgiving every year. Sometimes old "is" better! Thanks for the memories!!
ReplyDeleteDonna, this brings back memories of my childhood. This is almost exactly the sweet potato casserole that my mom would make every Thanksgiving. She didn't use rolled oats in the topping. Sometimes "old" is better! Thanks for bringing back the memories!!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDonna, my husband loves Sweet Potato Casserole and, fortuntely, I found them on sale for .39/pound. Since I am going to roast and freeze them for later use, can you tell me how many cups equal 3½ - 4 pounds? Thank you.
ReplyDeleteHi LaWanda. According to this site - there are approximately 2 cups mashed in one pound. Hope that helps.
Deletehttp://www.barryfarm.com/How_tos/how_many_cups_in_a_pound_of.htm
I am so sorry. I am new to the sight and was not aware of that information. Thank you for pointing it out.
ReplyDeleteOh no problem at all Lawanda! I actually had no idea, so I looked it up. The information I found was from a separate site, that I why I linked you too it. Feel free to ask any questions, any time!
DeleteEnjoy.
Pinning this! Love it!
ReplyDeleteHi Donna! Could I use yams instead??? HUBBY bought them thinking they
ReplyDeletewere sweet potatoes....these yams have dark skin and are orange inside.what do you think?
Hi Donna! Could I use yams instead??? HUBBY bought them thinking they
ReplyDeletewere sweet potatoes....these yams have dark skin and are orange inside.what do you think?
Yams would be fabulous! Happy Thanksgiving and let us know how it goes.
DeleteYams ARE sweet potatoes. They are the same.
DeleteThis looks so good! I feel like I make the same things year after so maybe I should try this one!
ReplyDeleteTotally different from mine. Pinning it and hope to try it!
ReplyDeleteI have canned sweet potatoes that I need to use, have you tried this?
ReplyDeleteDo you think it would make a big difference in taste?
Do you think this would freeze well? We're going to be out of town visiting families for a few days and I'd rather make it at home to take rather than make it at their house! lol
ReplyDeleteDo you remove the skin at any point?
ReplyDeleteYes, the recipe actually calls for peeled and cut sweet potatoes. Enjoy and let us know how it goes.
DeleteI'm debating whether to try this recipe or just buy the Boston Market version for Friendsgiving! I've tried making sweet potato casserole before but the results weren't that great. This recipe looks easy enough! I might try it. :)
ReplyDeleteMade this today ahead of time to have ready to put in the oven tomorrow for Thanksgiving. Had a couple test bites and omg I love this!!!! It's not too sweet like my sister makes and the vanilla really makes a difference. Thank you for sharing this wonderful recipe.Oh,and I used half milk and half and half and tastes yummy.
ReplyDeleteThat is so awesome. Happy you loved it!
DeleteHello! This looks soooo yummy :) do you use small or large marshmallows?
ReplyDeleteMini marshmallows would work best. Enjoy and let us know how it goes.
DeleteI'm not a fan of sweet potato casserole, or at least, I didn't think I was until trying this recipe. I made this for Thanksgiving this year, very delicious. Thank you for sharing!!
ReplyDeleteThat is great to hear. So happy you enjoyed it!
DeleteI made this recipe for Thanksgiving last month. It went over well and was requested for Christmas. Other than the peeling of the potatoes it's very easy to put together.
ReplyDeleteYes, if the potatoes only peeled themselves this would be an effortless dish. Perhaps a kitchen helper next time to help with the peeling. So glad you loved them.
DeleteI bake my potatoes when making sweet potato casserole. The taste seems much richer and they are easier to peel
DeleteThis is the best recipe i have found by far. Just made it and it's delicious.
ReplyDeleteAwesome! We love it and I am so happy to hear you do too.
DeleteTry using flavored creamer in it instead of heavy cream. There are non-fat and non sugar. I use it with any kind of squash. It's delish!
ReplyDeleteI have made a small one for myself as I live alone, 1/4'd the recipe .. I haven't had a desert style sweet potato before but I have had Grammer pie when I was a kid ... I sure it will be sensational
ReplyDeleteI made this recipe last month and we loved it. It freeze's well also. Thank You Lynn
ReplyDeleteMade this today, and me and my family gobbled it all up.lol Have to make a new batch for Thanksgiving! Thanks for sharing :)
ReplyDeleteThat is awesome! I am so happy you loved it. Have a Happy Thanksgiving!
DeleteI like mine really sweet. Would it be ok to add plain sugar in sweet potato mix along with the brown sugar?
ReplyDeleteThat would be perfectly fine. Enjoy and let us know how it goes!
DeleteHi, There. Made this last year, and it was FABULOUS! Thanks!!
ReplyDeleteCan you use canned yams? I sent my husband to the store because I forgot a few things. I said sweet potatoes and he brought back canned yams. :-) I will not have time to go to the store before I have to start cooking. If so, how many cups do you think I should use?
Thanks so much!!!
I am so happy you loved it! I have not used canned, but we have readers that have. I can not find a conversion for you. 1 pound equals 2 cups mashed so perhaps start by mashing them until you have the desired amount. If you are making the full recipe it would be 8 cups mashed. I even asked other readers on our FB page. https://www.facebook.com/SlowRoasted/photos/a.233687953348152.72003.192855430764738/1027292567321016/?type=3&theater
DeleteI would rinse them first. Enjoy and please let us know how it goes so we can share with our readers. Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family!
This looks amazing. I want to make ahead of time - is it best to make the whole thing and then reheat (and if so at what temp and for how long if its been in the fridge?) or is it better to save the last bit of baking for the day of? Thanks for any advice you can offer! Emily
ReplyDeleteMaking it fresh is best of course, but I am of the less stress is best mind set. I would prepare the sweet potatoes the day before and place them in your baking dish and prep the topping (but do not put it on top). Bring to room temperature the day of, add topping and bake.
DeleteEnjoy and let us know how it goes. Happy Thanksgiving!
Would it be ok to just use regular salted butter?
ReplyDeleteYes, you can use salted butter. Reduce the salt down by 1/4 teaspoon per 1/2 pound of butter.
DeleteEnjoy and let us know how it goes. Happy Thanksgiving Christina!
This was a great addition to my Thanksgiving dinner. Many many compliments. Thank you for such a great recipe yet again!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteHow long do they take to boil until they are fork tender?
ReplyDeleteI made this last year for Thanksgiving and then Christmas, It was a big hit and my family asked me to make it this year again for the Holidays. Thanks!!! It's very yummy and is definitely now a regular side dish at our family Holiday gatherings :)
ReplyDeleteIf i want to make this a day ahead of time, can I just cover and refrigerate? Or does it need to be frozen?
ReplyDeleteYou can refrigerate it, Amanda!
DeleteEnjoy and let me know how it goes. Happy Thanksgiving.
Easy and delicious !
ReplyDeleteLove how the jackets came off easily after baking vs boiling. Also the potatoes were not water logged using the baking method.
This recipe will be a yearly tradition. Thank you !
If you aren't against the micrtowave, do what I do. Stab the potatoes with a fork and nuke them on high til the are fork tender in the middle. Turn them over every 3 or 4 minutes til done. Cut in half and scoop out thgthge insides. Much easier on arthritic fingers than peeling and chopping!
ReplyDeleteThank you for your work in putting this together and posting it for the rest of us! My three girls have been traumatized ever since Boston Market closed both of its locations in my county—with the nearest now over an hour away. ;-( I made this for them over the weekend, and they were squealing with delight! ;-) I used light cream instead of heavy, and it seemed to be OK. Thank you again!
ReplyDeleteThank you Donna and Chad for always posting such delicious recipes!
ReplyDeleteThis is a luscious recipe, I use Splenda granular due to diabetes 2, no marshamallows, it turns out for anyone else with diabetes 2, the Splenda granular blend makes a better streusel. However, I have found that even non-sugar sweeteners still raise my blood sugar, though not as high or for as long as regular sugar. For many years, I have fixed my sweet potatoes with brown sugar (I now use the Splenda brown sugar blend), cinnamon, allspice and a dash of cloves, lots of butter, just a bit of milk and bourbon replaces the majority of the milk, lots of chpped pecans and baked in the oven without the marshmallows and this was before I was diagnosed with diabetes 2. The alcohol cooks out of the dish leaving a delicious flavor.
Hello,
ReplyDeleteI am looking forward to making this for Thanksgiving! :) I was just wondering if you double the recipe what size dish/container would you use? Also, do you know if you could you use a disposable pan when making this?
I doubled it a few years ago and used a 9x13 pan. If I had to do it again I would use my lasagna pan which is a little bigger than the 9x13. You can absolutely use a disposable pan, but it will be heavy and awkward. I would place the disposable pan on a baking sheet to add durability when transferring to the oven and when carrying.
DeleteEnjoy and let us know how it goes!
is this dessert or side dish that goes with meat?
ReplyDeleteIt is a side dish. Enjoy!
DeleteI have made this several times over the years and it is ALWAYS a hit!! My question is can it be hated through in a crockpot? My husband's work is having a Thanksgiving potluck with no stove in their break room and I don't want to hit the microwave!!
ReplyDeleteYou could warm it in a slow cooker. Be prepared to add liquid as it may dry out as it cooks. Enjoy and let us know how it goes.
DeleteCan I️ make this using quick oats instead of rolled oats?
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely!
DeleteJust wondering if anyone has incorporated chopped pecans into their streusel? Would that be ok or would it change the consistency too much?
ReplyDeleteI substituted pecans for the rolled oats and it came out wonderful!
DeleteI just made. Cooked last night. Can I reheat. Or should I just have everyone heat up in microwave
ReplyDeleteCan't wait to try this with gluten-free flour! In case anyone is interested I can comment on how it worked.
ReplyDeleteAnyone able to tell me how long it takes to make? Trying to time it right for lunch
ReplyDeleteDo you have to use oats? If I don't want adjustments should I make?
ReplyDeleteI have made this the past 2 thanksgiving and it has been a hit every time!
ReplyDeleteWe never have leftovers of it- I substitute Unsweetened Vanilla Almond Milk instead of the heavy cream-
I'm making this again for a Christmas potluck at work and hopefully they love it as much as my family does!
This recipe is my new go-to for any fall food occasion! I’m super-klutzy, so I microwaved the sweet potatoes, let them cool, and then removed the skins. Less likely to peel my knuckles that way! Everyone loves this dish—there are never leftovers!
ReplyDeleteI want to make ahead of time and freeze do I freeze before baking or after ? Love your
ReplyDeletesite.
I am going to double this recipe. Do I still cook at the same temp and time?
ReplyDeleteIs there any adjustments to this recipe if doubling as as far as ingredients or time? Thank you!
ReplyDeletewhat heavy cream did you use??
ReplyDelete